Whether you are seeking work, credit, a purchase, a service or a place to live, the three credit bureaus, Equifax, Transunion and Experian, have some influence on how you are treated as a consumer. Yet, they aren’t public service agencies, they aren’t consumer agencies, they are not beholden to the consumers whose credit they control or to the businesses that pay for their credit reporting information. They are large money-making corporations and they are making billions.
Every time they are mentioned in the news these days, it seems they are apathetic to the very consumers whose data they barter.
MSNBC reported in recent months that the FTC had charged Experian as a result of complaints.
Credit bureau Experian settled charges that it misled consumers with the lure of a free credit report and instead enrolled them in costly credit monitoring services, the Federal Trade Commission said.
Under the terms of the settlement, Experian admitted no wrongdoing but agreed to give refunds to some consumers and surrender $950,000 in what the FTC called “ill-gotten gains.” In addition, Experian, one of the nation’s three major credit bureaus, [had to change] the way it advertises credit monitoring services at ConsumerInfo.com and FreeCreditReport.com.
According to an article by Kim Zetter of Wired News,
“Equifax’s chief executive says he opposes federal legislation that lets consumers obtain a free copy of their credit report to help them monitor financial accounts for fraudulent activity.” While speaking to a group of reporters in San Francisco, CEO Thomas Chapman called the legislation “unconstitutional and un-American because it cuts into profits that Equifax and [it’s two rivals, Experian and Transunion,] earn from selling credit reports and monitoring services. Equifax maintains data on 220 million Americans [and earned] $1.27 billion in revenue last year.”
Trafficking in personal data is the focus of their business: selling your name, address, phone, credit history, etc. to marketers/companies that want to sell you something. Ensuring that your credit history is accurate and that you are not victimized by fraudulent activity is not the focus of their business.
If the credit bureaus weren’t influencing almost every aspect of our daily lives by what they tell businesses, lenders, and creditors about us, it would be such a huge issue. Now, however, reporting inaccuracies can cost consumers significant amounts of money. The more businesses rely on what the credit bureaus report to determine how they will treat consumers, the more impact those inaccuracies have on consumers’ finances.
It may be time for legislators and businesses to evaluate the influence and control of the credit bureaus. Protecting consumers’ rights, resources and data should be foremost in the evaluation process. If the credit bureaus are unable or unwilling to ensure accuracy, privacy and protection, then another method for establishing and maintaining consumer credit must be found.